Supervisor Yvette Aguiar addressed police department and ambulance district funding at the Nov. 3 town board meeting. Pictured with the supervisor, center, are Council Members Catherine Kent and Ken Rothwell, and, foreground, Town Clerk Diane Wilhelm and Town Attorney Robert Kozakiewicz. Photo: Denise Civiletti

The town board public hearing on its preliminary budget for 2022 was wrapped at yesterday afternoon’s board meeting without any public comment.

The board chose to go to hearing on the supervisor’s tentative budget, filed on Sept. 30, without revision.

The operating budget proposal calls for a 1.4% reduction in the town-wide tax rate. The tax rate would drop 80 cents per $1,000 of assessed value, from $58.00 per $1,000 to $57.20 per $1,000.

It also calls for a 2.1% spending increase, which Supervisor Yvette Aguiar in the written budget message accompanying her tentative budget said Aguiar said was offset by saving money in fiscal year 2021 and utilizing non-tax sources of revenue such as federal coronavirus relief and community benefit funds received as a result of agreements with solar energy companies constructing power facilities in Calverton.

After Riverhead financial administrator William Rothaar presented a brief overview of the budget proposal, Aguiar brought up the budget allocations for the police department and Riverhead Volunteer Ambulance Corps.

“There was some question earlier — within the last few weeks — claiming that the police department budget was decreased and it was actually increased and can you — I think we discussed the figures a while ago,” Aguiar said, addressing Rothaar at the podium. “Do you have those? Does she have it?” she asked, apparently referring to her opponent in the just-concluded election campaign, Councilwoman Catherine Kent.

In the weeks leading up to the election, Kent had questioned why the supervisor’s 2022 tentative budget for police vehicles and equipment dropped from $289,250 in the 2021 adopted budget to $106,900 in 2022 — when the department had requested $526,900 in that category. In some campaign advertisements, Kent accused Aguiar of “ignoring public safety and underfunding our police,” which angered the supervisor, a retired NYC police detective sergeant, who as supervisor, serves as police commissioner.

“We just want to let the police department know that they received well over an extra million dollars,” Aguiar said. “And they got the equipment. And there were lines where — at one point there was a line identifying equipment last year. And we reduced it this year because we’re paying for those cars this year. And that’s what good budgeting is. You adjust and you’re not going to take those funds that were issued last year and then we’re going to get them the equipment and then roll ‘em over. That’s what budgeting is all about, moving your numbers and giving the people what they need.”

Rothaar explained that overall spending for police department is increased $1,235,000 for 2022, including an $870,000 operating budget increase, $100,000 for training and equipment from the NextEra/L.I. Solar Center community benefits agreement and the expenditure of $165,000 in 2021 for three police vehicles. The funding for the vehicles came from higher-than-expected sales tax revenues, Rothaar said. He noted that the town board passed a budget adjustment resolution for this “two or three meetings ago.”

Kent asked Chief David Hegermiller if the allocations meet the department’s needs for vehicles and equipment.

“The bad news is, we just lost another car the other night in an accident,” Hegermiller told the board from the podium.

“And you know what? Those are the things that myself as the chief financial officer and our financial administrator will be discussing with you,” the supervisor told the chief.

Aguiar also brought up the complaints of the Riverhead Volunteer Ambulance Corps regarding the funding it receives from the ambulance district to provide emergency medical services within the district, which takes in the entire town exclusive of the Wading River Fire District. See Nov. 1 story, “‘We can’t sustain this’ — Riverhead Volunteer Ambulance Corps says it lacks funds needed to serve residents.“

“There was some recent indicators from the RVAC — the Riverhead Volunteer,” Aguiar said. “I know that we went through an exhaustive amount of time to try to speak to them. I cleared my schedule for two days. We gave them options. We emailed. We called. And they still haven’t provided us with the annual accounting for last year. And we haven’t been able to reach them,” Aguiar said.

RVAC president Garrett Lake said the town sent an email advising the corps of a meeting date and time but sent it to an incorrect email address — his personal email address he no longer uses, despite having communicated with the town from his RVAC email account. When RVAC did not attend the meeting, which Lake said the group knew nothing about, no one reached out to find out why, he said, and instead prepared the tentative budget without the group’s input.

The amount budgeted was not sufficient to allow RVAC to function, Lake said. The ambulance district is responding to more than 4,000 calls per year and the organization must rely on an increasing number of paid responders to cover the district, he said. RVAC sought a $544,000 increase, which town officials said was untenable.

Aguiar said yesterday the town “finally got a meeting with them.”

The meeting, attended by Rothaar and Deputy Town Attorney Dan McCormick, took place on Oct. 25. McCormick has been in contract negotiations with RVAC’s attorney. RVAC’s contract with the town, which has traditionally covered a five-year period, expired over a year ago, Lake said.

Rothaar said the town’s contract with RVAC calls for a 1% annual increase, and that was provided in the budget.

“We met that contract,” Aguiar said “And we also provided additional funding. So just discuss that, clear it once and for all,” she told Rothaar.

Rothaar said RVAC came to the Oct. 25 meeting with an amended request that was $50,000 higher than what the town provided in its budget. He said the town can provide that amount from $40,000 in “other revenues” and $10,000 from fund balance. The town could do that without amending the 2022 budget, he said.

“We also gave them another $120,000,” Rothaar said. “We gave them $50,000 for a vehicle. We gave them $70,000 for training.” Those funds were allocated from the NextEra/L.I. Solar Center community benefits agreement and approved by the town board in a resolution yesterday. “So we gave them, the 1% plus $120,000,” Rothaar told the board.

“There’s a lot of documentation that’s missing,” Aguiar said yesterday during the hearing, which representatives from RVAC did not attend. “And as the chief financial officer, I will not complete a budget without an annual accounting,” she said.

Rothaar said he asked RVAC for a couple of other reports, “which we’re getting from the auditors,” he said.

“We need to clarify this for the public,” Aguiar said. “There’s been some misunderstanding, and we need to ensure that we fund them, the RVAC,” she said. “It’s important that we keep our RVAC going. Unfortunately, I don’t know how it got to this state. And our budget is done. And finally, we have accommodated them,” she said.

Rothaar said he discussed with RVAC the need for “open communications, even on a monthly basis, so we don’t get to this point, next June, July, or even in preparation for the budget that’s due to us on Aug. 1.”

Councilman Tim Hubbard, the town board liaison to the ambulance corps, did not participate in yesterday’s discussion. He acknowledged in an interview last month that he has not met with RVAC board members to discuss their budget concerns.

“I understand that that it has been a trend throughout the years. And again, we’re not going to create a sloppy budget,” Aguiar said.

“We’ll be addressing any concerns any department has,” the supervisor said. “I know that Tim [Hubbard] will be meeting with me. Catherine, you’re more than welcome to meet with me and discuss any concerns you have and of course Ken, if you have any concerns,” Aguiar said.

“And that’s the way budgets are done. And it’s open. We’re here. This is a public hearing for the public to chime in and we’re going to keep our budget where it is,” Aguiar said. “I mean it’s a good budget and we have to move things around and we’re going to move them around and I look forward to having a meeting with the rest of the board on the budget,” she said.

“And I would like to discuss it at work session, because it is the public’s money,” Kent told the supervisor.

None of the other board members said anything about the budget during the hearing. The board has not had a public budget discussion since the supervisor filed her tentative budget Sept. 30.

It’s not clear when a work session budget discussion might take place between now and the the town board’s deadline to adopt a final budget, Nov. 20, which is set by state law. There is no work session today and Town Hall is closed next Thursday in observance of Veterans Day. No alternative work session day next week has been announced. The town’s next regular board meeting is the following Tuesday, Nov. 16, which would be the last regular meeting before the board’s budget deadline. If the board does not adopt a budget on or before that date, the town board’s preliminary budget will become the 2022 final budget by operation of law.

The supervisor left the budget hearing record open for written comment until Friday, Nov. 12 at 4:30 p.m. Comments should be submitted to the town clerk.

The survival of local journalism depends on your support.
We are a small family-owned operation. You rely on us to stay informed, and we depend on you to make our work possible. Just a few dollars can help us continue to bring this important service to our community.
Support RiverheadLOCAL today.

Avatar photo
Denise is a veteran local reporter, editor and attorney. Her work has been recognized with numerous journalism awards, including investigative reporting and writer of the year awards from the N.Y. Press Association. She was also honored in 2020 with a NY State Senate Woman of Distinction Award for her trailblazing work in local online news. She is a founder, owner and co-publisher of this website. Email Denise.