To the Editor:
At the July 22 Town Board meeting, I was shocked to learn that Riverhead’s new downtown square project is to be awarded to developer Petrocelli without public bidding or consideration of other proposals. How is this acceptable?
The Board defends its decision by citing Petrocelli’s past work—the Aquarium, the Hyatt Hotel, and the Preston House. But this isn’t just about a track record. It’s about fairness, transparency, and whether this plan truly benefits our community.
The new proposal includes a five-story building with 12 condominiums—each with only one designated parking spot. Based on a “condo-hotel” model used in cities like Miami, it may entice tourists, but is it right for Riverhead’s long-term needs?
A café is also planned for Main Street, open to hotel guests and the public. But will it be affordable for everyday residents, or designed to attract visitors?
Many locals voiced frustration at the meeting. There’s rising concern that our needs are being sidelined for private interests and short-term gains. Earlier plans envisioned walkable streets, local shops, and artist lofts. Why aren’t we revisiting those?
Financial transparency is another red flag. As resident Angela DeVito pointed out, a new Petrocelli LLC was quietly formed in May. Under the deal, Petrocelli maintains the space for only 10 years—after which the burden may shift to taxpayers. One resident even quipped that he’d like a tax abatement too, like the one reportedly planned for Petrocelli.
Just look at Southold and Greenport—thriving communities with rich history, no towering buildings, and resident-focused planning. Riverhead deserves the same thoughtful approach. Wouldn’t it be nice to walk down Main Street and see a clear view to the Riverfront, vs his version of a Miami style condo-hotel?
The Town Board is accepting public comments only through Friday, Aug. 1 at 4 p.m. If you care about building height, parking, affordability, or preserving Riverhead’s character, now is the time to speak up.
Send your thoughts to: wooten@townofriverheadny.gov Your letter will be officially recorded.
Developer Petrocelli has the means and skill to build another hotel—but is that truly what best serves our community’s long-term needs and vision? He has already received three tax abatements from our community for past projects, is another one necessary?
Speak now, or risk being unheard. Let’s shape the future of Riverhead together.
Gina Ristau
Aquebogue
The survival of local journalism depends on your support.
We are a small family-owned operation. You rely on us to stay informed, and we depend on you to make our work possible. Just a few dollars can help us continue to bring this important service to our community.
Support RiverheadLOCAL today.
