Interim Assistant Superintendent for Business Marianne Cartisano at the April 9, 2025 school board meeting. RiverheadLOCAL/Alek Lewis

All problems cited by the state comptroller’s office in its audit of the Riverhead Central School District’s financial operations have been corrected, Interim Assistant Superintendent for Business Marianne Cartisano told the board of education at its Jan. 14 meeting.

Cartisano walked the board through the audit findings and the district’s corrective action plan. At the conclusion of her presentation, the board voted to accept the audit report and approve the corrective action plan, which is required to be filed with the comptroller’s office.

The audit covered July 1, 2022 through April 30, 2024. It found problems across multiple areas of the district’s financial operations, including late and inaccurate monthly reporting to the board, weak internal controls in the business office, and budget transfers that were not properly approved or reported. District officials’ failure to provide the board of education with complete and accurate financial information in a timely manner limited the board’s ability to monitor the district’s financial operations, according to the report.

The audit cited late reporting to the board and found that 141 bank transfers totaling $127 million lacked independent pre-approval and that 47 budget transfers over $25,000 totaling $12.3 million were not approved by the board. See: State audit faults Riverhead schools for weak financial oversight in 2022–2024

“There were no improprieties and there were no funds missing,” Cartisano said.

There were also “no surprises,” she said.

Cartisano: These were the problems I was hired to address

“We’re aware that when I got here, some of the things I did immediately — and with a $200 million budget we had some things to fix,” Cartisano said. “You discovered that. That’s why I’m here.”

Cartisano was hired as interim assistant superintendent for business on Oct. 30, 2023, along with interim superintendent Cheryl Pedisich, after the departure that month of Superintendent Augustine Tornatore and assistant superintendent for business Rodney Asse. (Asse was administratively assigned at home with full pay and benefits until Dec. 25, 2023, when his resignation became effective.)

“There were seven audit comments. And I’m proud to say, out of the seven audit comments, every one of them had already been rectified” before the audit report was issued, Cartisano said. “Because when I got here in October of ’23, we’d already started fixing things. That’s why you hired me to be part of this transition team,” she said.

The first four recommendations in the audit report had already been completed before the auditors arrived in Riverhead in May 2024, Cartisano said, and the rest were already in the process of being completed.

The first four recommendations dealt with the timeliness of reporting by the former district treasurer, the failure of the former treasurer to perform bank reconciliations, and the failure of the former superintendent and former business official to review the treasurer’s reconciliations and reports, she said.

Correction of the other problems the auditors cited, having to do with internal controls and segregation of duties within the business office, was already underway, Cartisano said.

“We had already spoken about that,” she told the board. “You had already hired somebody to start in April, and that was the new accountant. You had already given me permission to hire a business manager. That was already done prior to [the auditors] getting here,” Cartisano said. The district had already increased claims auditing responsibilities, which she said was finished during the audit process, and procedures for budget transfers were developed during the audit process, she said.

“So every one of these seven items was either fixed prior to them arriving or during the audit process,” Cartisano told the board.

“Now they can’t note that in the report,” Cartisano said, because the audit ended in April 2024. “I now get the opportunity to stand here and say it publicly. I also get the opportunity to put it in writing in your corrective action plan,” she said. “It’s the easiest audit report I’ve ever responded to.”

The work done to correct the problems she found when she was hired by the district in fall 2023 was “a collaborative effort, starting at the board level and rolling down right through the field,” Cartisano said.

Cartisano to board members: ‘You had guardrails’ that ‘slipped away’

Board member Virginia Healy said the district’s internal auditors had made recommendations regarding internal controls, which she said were made public on June 11, 2024. The internal audit talks about internal controls and “brought up all of these issues which you took care of,” Healy said. The district did not have a treasurer with an accounting background or experience, she said. “So this was not something that was just put off.”

Cartisano told Healy that policies and procedures had been in place “years before” but some had “stopped being enforced” during Covid and “your personnel changes,” she said.

“So you had guardrails on, and then you hit a period when you didn’t,” Cartisano said. “Even prior to July ’22 for many years, you had many of these controls in place. They kind of just slipped away a little bit,” she said. She did not go into details.

The personnel changes cited by Cartisano

Before the board hired Asse in May 2022, the district’s business office was led by Deputy Superintendent Sam Schneider, who had served as the district’s business official since 2011. Schneider was ousted from his position in October 2021 amid an investigation involving an employee, and the district later hired the accounting firm Nawrocki Smith of Melville to conduct a forensic audit. The forensic audit, released in June 2022, found no evidence of fraud, embezzlement or malfeasance.

By the time the forensic audit was presented publicly, Schneider was no longer with the district. He resigned from Riverhead in March 2022 after entering into a settlement agreement with the district and took a job as assistant superintendent for business at the East Hampton school district, a position he still holds. Last year, Schneider received the Gregory E. Carlson Outstanding School Business Official of the Year Award from the Association of School Business Officials of New York.

Asse was hired May 24, 2022 on Tornatore’s recommendation. Tornatore previously worked with Asse at Liberty Central School District. Before Liberty, Asse served as budget director in the Rochester City School District from January 2017 to September 2019, resigning shortly after that district’s budget deficit became public. The disclosure later prompted a state comptroller audit and state oversight. The comptroller’s April 2020 report did not lay blame for the situation on any single official, including Asse, but said the underbudgeted appropriations “should have reasonably been estimated by the District’s Central Office.”

Both Tornatore and Asse left the district in October 2023. The board then appointed Interim Superintendent Cheryl Pedisich and Interim Assistant Superintendent for Business Marianne Cartisano.

The survival of local journalism depends on your support.
We are a small family-owned operation. You rely on us to stay informed, and we depend on you to make our work possible. Just a few dollars can help us continue to bring this important service to our community.
Support RiverheadLOCAL today.

Avatar photo
Denise is a veteran local reporter, editor and attorney. Her work has been recognized with numerous journalism awards, including investigative reporting and writer of the year awards from the N.Y. Press Association. She was also honored in 2020 with a NY State Senate Woman of Distinction Award for her trailblazing work in local online news. She is a founder, owner and co-publisher of this website. Email Denise.